Moor Studio/Getty Images

Ueland’s GAO nomination puts Congress’s power of the purse to the test

COMMENTARY | As OMB’s deputy director, Eric Ueland has been part of an administration at odds with the Government Accountability Office over its authority to withhold appropriated funds. Senators should press him on whether he will lead an independent watchdog.

President Donald Trump’s nomination of Eric Ueland, the White House Office of Management and Budget’s deputy director for management, to a 15-year term as comptroller general and head of the Government Accountability Office puts a constitutional dispute directly before Congress.

With his confirmation hearing scheduled for this week, the Senate should begin with two basic questions: Does the administration believe it is bound by the spending laws Congress has enacted? And will the nominee uphold GAO’s independent interpretation of spending law, even when it conflicts with the administration he now serves?

At the center of this debate is a disagreement between OMB and GAO over impoundment, the withholding or delay of budget authority Congress has appropriated. GAO has identified unlawful impoundments by executive agencies and concluded that a president cannot use a late-year rescission proposal to hold funds until they expire without congressional approval.

The power to manage is not the power to repeal

Under Article I of the Constitution, Congress sets the legal terms of spending, and the executive branch administers funds within those terms.

That arrangement leaves room for executive judgment, but it does not turn an appropriation into a suggestion. The Impoundment Control Act of 1974 grew out of a clash between Congress and President Richard Nixon over his refusal to spend appropriated funds. Under the law, a president may ask Congress to cancel spending and temporarily withhold the funds for 45 days of continuous session of Congress, as defined by the law. Unless Congress approves the rescission within that window, the funds must be made available for obligation.

An administration can argue that a program is wasteful. OMB can recommend eliminating it. The president can make the case publicly and ask Congress to act. But policy disagreement is not permission to disregard statutory spending requirements.

Ueland’s nomination and the administration’s use of so-called pocket rescissions, a disputed maneuver for running out the clock on appropriations, raise the stakes for Congress and federal agencies, especially in fiscal years 2027 and 2028.

On Sept. 25, 2026, the White House proposed rescissions totaling approximately $810 million across 11 accounts affecting programs at the departments of Commerce, Education, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security, Housing and Urban Development, and Justice, as well as International Assistance Programs administered by Treasury. OMB withheld the funds from obligation. GAO concluded that the law does not permit withholding funds beyond their expiration date, in this case September 30, 2026.

OMB Director Russell Vought has taken the opposite position, arguing that the law permits withholding funds for the full 45-day consideration period even when that period extends past expiration, allowing the money to lapse before Congress can act.

While the Supreme Court has not issued a final ruling on the merits, it allowed the administration to continue withholding funds in a September 2025 emergency order. The court said the administration had made a sufficient preliminary showing that the Impoundment Control Act barred the plaintiffs’ lawsuit, but emphasized that its order was not a final determination on the merits. The Senate should not treat this nomination as routine or wait on the courts.

Before advancing the appointment, Senate lawmakers should put this legal dispute at the center of the confirmation hearing:

  • Does the nominee agree with OMB’s position that a rescission request permits withholding funds through expiration without congressional approval, or with GAO’s conclusion that such withholding is unlawful?

  • What role, if any, did the nominee play in developing or implementing OMB’s position, and what legal analysis supported it?

  • What instructions did OMB give agencies regarding the 2025 and 2026 rescission proposals, and when were agencies told that affected funds might expire?

  • Will the nominee preserve GAO’s independent review of OMB actions, including those in which he participated, and how would he handle resulting conflicts of interest?

The answers will determine whether an administration can alter enacted spending decisions simply by controlling the calendar.

GAO’s statutory role makes independence essential

GAO has explicit statutory duties under the Impoundment Control Act to review rescission messages and report unlawful impoundments to Congress. Its appropriations-law decisions give lawmakers a concrete, nonpartisan record of executive compliance.

Senators should examine how GAO’s existing findings will be handled under new GAO leadership. For each finding of unlawful withholding, Congress needs a full accounting of OMB’s instructions, agency communications, legal rationale and chronology, establishing who authorized the hold, what authority they relied upon and whether funds were later released for obligation. At the same time, GAO’s credibility rests on distinguishing lawful implementation delays from policy-driven withholding; its published decisions include both violations and no-violation findings.

Ueland's prior service at OMB does not disqualify him from leading GAO independently. But senators should establish whether he can put the agency's independent legal responsibilities ahead of his former employer's interests, including when GAO reviews actions he helped develop or implement.

Congress must defend its own decisions

The question underlying the disagreement between GAO and OMB is not whether every appropriation is wise. Congress makes mistakes, and presidents are entitled to challenge its priorities through the legislative process. (As a former agency budget official, I’ve helped administrations of both parties make their case to Congress.) The issue is whether any administration, Republican or Democratic, may treat its objection to a law as authority to change that law’s effect without congressional approval.

If Congress is going to defend its power of the purse, lawmakers must insist on a GAO leader who will preserve the institution as an independent check on the executive branch.

Gene Lockwood-Shabat is a former senior federal executive with nearly three decades of public service across five federal agencies. From 2022 to 2025 he served as associate deputy assistant secretary for Planning and Performance Management at the Department of Veterans Affairs and VA’s Performance Improvement Officer.