The contested 2000 Bush v. Gore election presented a challenge for GSA.

The contested 2000 Bush v. Gore election presented a challenge for GSA. Robert F. Bukaty/AP file photo

Using Data to Support Decision Making
Smart Cities: Beyond the Buzz
Future of the Army
GSA Chief Could Be in the Hot Seat if a Defeated Trump Won’t Concede

Transition law gives agency chief sole authority to ascertain election winner.

This story has been updated

Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump’s debate bombshell hinting that he might contest the results of the Nov. 8 election should he lose has ears perked up at one federal agency in particular.

The General Services Administration, under presidential transition laws going back to 1963, is responsible once election returns are clear for ascertaining which party’s candidates are the “apparent” new president-elect and vice-president-elect.

And though that sober task became a challenge one time—during the contested 2000 Bush v. Gore election whose recounts extended into December—criteria for making the declaration, veterans of the process tell Government Executive, are left to the GSA administrator. That’s because with only 73 days until the Inauguration, there’s no time to waste in outfitting the incoming team in its new digs with space, equipment and travel funds. "

"Consistent with past practice of GSA administrators in Republican and Democratic administrations, [the decision on which candidate will get office space and resources] typically happens in the days immediately following the conclusion of the election," a GSA spokeswoman said.

Under the 1963 Presidential Transition Law (amended in 2010 and 2016), the “president-elect” and “vice-president-elect” are defined as “the apparent successful candidates for the office of president and vice president, respectively, as ascertained by the administrator following the general elections.” 

The law “doesn’t say anything about how to decide—it could be tea leaves or newspapers,” said Jim Williams, who as acting GSA chief in November 2008 determined Barack Obama and Joe Biden were the “apparent winners” of that election (pending formal designation by the Electoral College weeks later). Whether Trump issues a concession should not affect the call, Williams said, because of the shortage of time.

Sitting in the prepared and secured transition space in Washington on election night, Williams watched the televised returns and decided, at about 11:00 p.m. EST when Obama had 215 electoral votes, that the Democrat was likely to take California and top the needed 270. “I’m ready to sign,” he told staff.

So in a ceremony that GSA captured on video, Williams—following some snafus in efforts to re-type three formal messages on GSA letterhead—signed documents addressed to Obama, Republican losing candidate John McCain, and a memo to the GSA’s chief financial officer authorizing the turnover of $6 million of the $8 million designated for transition.

 “I and the members of the GSA Presidential Transition Support Team look forward to supporting you during this transition period and throughout your administration,” one letter said.

“This is an historic moment for our nation and for GSA,” said Presidential Transition Director Gail Lovelace. “Our team has worked more than two years to complete this headquarters and help facilitate the orderly transfer of executive power.”

McCain conceded the race, and Williams called Obama deputy campaign chief Chris Lu, whose team showed up at the transition space bright and early the next day.

In determining the apparent winners, the GSA administrator “doesn’t consider just one thing, but has to look at the whole picture,” Lovelace told Government Executive. This year, if Trump were to lose the vote count and decline to concede, “The White House and GSA would have to evaluate what’s going on, what are the next steps,” she said. 

The GSA chief during the roller-coaster drama of the 2000 recount had a rougher time. With Democratic candidate Al Gore having won the popular vote, but the parties in court and the state of Florida conducting a dramatic recount for its prize electoral votes, GSA Administrator David Barram, and later acting chief Thurman Davis, Lovelace recalled, took flak from both parties for refusing to promptly hand over the keys, funds and office space.

As Slate reported in December 2000 during the drama, “It would be a great public relations coup for either Bush or Al Gore to convince Barram that he will be the next commander in chief.”

Even before the litigation and recounting were ended by the Supreme Court, Republican vice presidential candidate Dick Cheney said at a Nov. 27, 2000, press conference, “Now that the election results in Florida have been certified, in accordance with Florida state law and rulings by the Florida Supreme Court, we believe it is time to get on with the business of organizing the new administration. We were disappointed, therefore, when the General Services Administration announced that they will continue to deny us access to taxpayer funds that are specifically appropriated by the Congress and set aside to pay for the transition.”

Cheney added: “This is regrettable, because we believe the government has an obligation to honor the certified results of the election…Therefore, at the direction of Governor [George W.] Bush, we will proceed, drawing on other sources.” The Bush team set up offices within McLean, Va., with its own funds. 

GSA would wait until December 14, after the Supreme Court ruled in favor of the Republicans and Gore had conceded, to turn over the keys and funds for the shortened 2000 transition. “In this unprecedented, incredibly close and intensely contested election, with legal action being pursued by both sides, it [was] not apparent to me who the winner [was],” Barram later told the House Government Reform Government Management Subcommittee. He cited 1963 House floor debate on the Presidential Transition Act in which a sponsor said, “in a close contest, the administrator simply would not make the decision.”

The 2016 version of the law, as noted by the nonprofit Partnership for Public Service's transition project, does appear to make allowances for a period of uncertainty about the winning candidates, reading, “An eligible candidate shall have a right to the services and facilities described in this paragraph until the date on which the administrator is able to determine the apparent successful candidates for the office of president and vice president.''

Next month, presuming there is Election Night clarity on the winner, the document signing ceremony by current Administrator Denise Turner Roth will be held at GSA’s F Street Northwest Headquarters, where permanent transition space is now ready.