Regulatory Turf War

September 10, 1996

Regulatory Turf War

A 10-year-old regulatory tug-of-war involving at least eight federal agencies has tied up congressional attempts to make the laws governing U.S. futures trading more efficient and effective, while many key government and industry officials say the best proposal may be no proposal at all.

After six months of hearings and steady staff work, Senate Agriculture Chairman Lugar and ranking member Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., have pushed back introduction of their bipartisan bill to reform the Commodity Exchange Act, and now plan to offer only a "discussion document" before Congress adjourns, aides said in recent interviews. At issue is a provision in the bill that attempts to clarify the so- called Treasury amendment to the CEA, which excluded certain foreign currency, government securities and a limited number of other transactions from the supervisory jurisdiction of the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.

By far the bulk of the multi-trillion-dollar-a-day exempted transactions are conducted by banks and overseen by bank regulators. But leaders of the seven U.S. futures exchanges have asked Congress to give their regulator, the CFTC, clear supervisory authority over retail transactions that fall into a regulatory gap where there is no clear enforcement authority to try to prevent a fraudulent or other criminal practice from taking place.

"Unregulated bucket shops, Internet dealers and even the retail trading desks of currency dealers are taking advantage of the public, evading the intense regulation mandated for futures trading and siphoning liquidity away from markets," explained Jack Sandner, chairman of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, in recent testimony before the Senate panel. However, those opposed to the legislative fix contend retail transactions account for such a small amount of the market that the CFTC has issued enforcement actions against only a handful in the last decade.

"Before we bring federal intervention into a private market, we need to ask whether there is enough of a problem out there to warrant a whole new regulatory structure. It doesn't sound like there is a terribly big problem," commented an official at the Federal Reserve, one of the agencies in a presidential working group considering this issue. "Legislation may also severely limit a bank's ability to provide customer- tailored [products] to their customers."

In preparing their bill, Lugar and Leahy asked Treasury and CFTC officials to work out a solution to clarify federal law and jurisdiction in this area. They were unable to do so in the time specified, and Agriculture Committee staff are saying the senators may leave the Treasury amendment out of their bill for now. "We think there should be legislation to fill the gap, and we want to craft a solution carefully enough so that it does not push the market off-shore or adversely effect the markets or the banks. That's why it is taking so long," a Treasury official explained.

The negotiations on a solution now have been expanded, he said, to include the other members of the presidential working group, the SEC, the Fed, the Fed Bank of New York, the FDIC and the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Still, industry and government opponents say this is really a turf battle between regulators looking to expand their jurisdictions, in this case giving the CFTC a monopoly over exchanges on trades of less than $5 million. "The foreign currency and government-securities markets have functioned effectively without CFTC involvement for the past 100 years. Who is making an effective case for CFTC jurisdiction?" asked Mark Brickell, managing director at J.P. Morgan and a board member of the International Swaps and Derivatives Association.

A CFTC official said this over-the-counter market is "rife with fraud" by unregistered companies.

There is a case pending before the Supreme Court to address a part of this question, but Congress should not wait for the courts to decide, he said, adding, "The best thing would be for the CFTC and Treasury to decide."

Stay up-to-date with federal news alerts and analysis — Sign up for GovExec's email newsletters.
Close [ x ] More from GovExec

Thank you for subscribing to newsletters from
We think these reports might interest you:

  • Sponsored by G Suite

    Cross-Agency Teamwork, Anytime and Anywhere

    Dan McCrae, director of IT service delivery division, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)

  • Data-Centric Security vs. Database-Level Security

    Database-level encryption had its origins in the 1990s and early 2000s in response to very basic risks which largely revolved around the theft of servers, backup tapes and other physical-layer assets. As noted in Verizon’s 2014, Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR)1, threats today are far more advanced and dangerous.

  • Sponsored by One Identity

    One Nation Under Guard: Securing User Identities Across State and Local Government

    In 2016, the government can expect even more sophisticated threats on the horizon, making it all the more imperative that agencies enforce proper identity and access management (IAM) practices. In order to better measure the current state of IAM at the state and local level, Government Business Council (GBC) conducted an in-depth research study of state and local employees.

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    The Next Federal Evolution of Cloud

    This GBC report explains the evolution of cloud computing in federal government, and provides an outlook for the future of the cloud in government IT.

  • Sponsored by LTC Partners, administrators of the Federal Long Term Care Insurance Program

    Approaching the Brink of Federal Retirement

    Approximately 10,000 baby boomers are reaching retirement age per day, and a growing number of federal employees are preparing themselves for the next chapter of their lives. Learn how to tackle the challenges that today's workforce faces in laying the groundwork for a smooth and secure retirement.

  • Sponsored by Hewlett Packard Enterprise

    Cyber Defense 101: Arming the Next Generation of Government Employees

    Read this issue brief to learn about the sector's most potent challenges in the new cyber landscape and how government organizations are building a robust, threat-aware infrastructure

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    GBC Issue Brief: Cultivating Digital Services in the Federal Landscape

    Read this GBC issue brief to learn more about the current state of digital services in the government, and how key players are pushing enhancements towards a user-centric approach.


When you download a report, your information may be shared with the underwriters of that document.