Study highlights differences between military, civilian leaders

A recent study on leadership and management found significant differences between the military services and the nonservice agencies within the Defense Department.

The study, conducted by researchers at Princeton University, found that while senior officials at the military services received higher evaluations from employees than their nonservice counterparts in the areas of leadership and work climate, they did not score as well on management.

"These findings highlight the profession-bureaucracy tradeoff within the Defense Department," the study said. "The military services focus on the cultivation of leaders while civilian agency leaders focus on organizational performance."

The study was based on data from the Office of Personnel Management's 2002 and 2004 surveys of the federal workforce. They captured the perspectives of employees at 58 agencies within the Defense Department, though not all of the agencies were included both years.

From 3 percent to 9 percent more employees in the Army, Navy and Air Force reported high levels of respect for their senior leaders than did employees at the nonservice agencies, the study found. Service members also were between 1 percent and 7 percent more likely to report that their leaders generated high levels of motivation and commitment.

Between 5.5 percent and 8 percent more employees in the military services indicated that they would recommend their organization as a good place to work.

The findings were more varied in the area of management, but there was no overarching pattern of the services rating better than the nonservice agencies.

The services regularly rotate their staff members through different positions, giving them the chance to enhance leadership skills, the researchers noted. This practice is less common in the civilian agencies, under the theory that it may hurt management of specific programs, the researchers said.

The study found that for each additional year managers had served in a specific position, their employees were 2.5 percent to 5 percent more likely to report that they reviewed progress toward organizational goals, and 1.5 percent to 3 percent more likely to report that their organization had the knowledge and skills necessary to accomplish the goals.

John Palguta, vice president for policy and research at the nonprofit Partnership for Public Service in Washington, said there should be a middle ground between job rotation and tenure.

"It has to be tempered with the fact that you don't want workers to be vagabonds," he said. "You want some rotation but you also want to take advantage of what they're learning on a leadership level and give them a chance to stay in an organization long enough to mature as managers."

Additionally, the study found that across the Defense Department, executives with higher levels of education and private sector management experience scored five to 10 points better on all survey questions.

With significant changes in the workforce expected in the next five to 10 years as large numbers of employees retire, government recruiters seeking to fill senior positions should begin to look more expansively at experience, whether inside or outside of public service, Palguta said.

He added it is unlikely that the leadership and management assessment of Defense would change much based on the results of the 2006 OPM workforce survey. But, he said, it would "be very interesting to see what the new numbers are."

Stay up-to-date with federal news alerts and analysis — Sign up for GovExec's email newsletters.
Close [ x ] More from GovExec

Thank you for subscribing to newsletters from
We think these reports might interest you:

  • Sponsored by Brocade

    Best of 2016 Federal Forum eBook

    Earlier this summer, Federal and tech industry leaders convened to talk security, machine learning, network modernization, DevOps, and much more at the 2016 Federal Forum. This eBook includes a useful summary highlighting the best content shared at the 2016 Federal Forum to help agencies modernize their network infrastructure.

  • Sponsored by CDW-G

    GBC Flash Poll Series: Merger & Acquisitions

    Download this GBC Flash Poll to learn more about federal perspectives on the impact of industry consolidation.

  • Sponsored by One Identity

    One Nation Under Guard: Securing User Identities Across State and Local Government

    In 2016, the government can expect even more sophisticated threats on the horizon, making it all the more imperative that agencies enforce proper identity and access management (IAM) practices. In order to better measure the current state of IAM at the state and local level, Government Business Council (GBC) conducted an in-depth research study of state and local employees.

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    The Next Federal Evolution of Cloud

    This GBC report explains the evolution of cloud computing in federal government, and provides an outlook for the future of the cloud in government IT.

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    A DevOps Roadmap for the Federal Government

    This GBC Report discusses how DevOps is steadily gaining traction among some of government's leading IT developers and agencies.

  • Sponsored by LTC Partners, administrators of the Federal Long Term Care Insurance Program

    Approaching the Brink of Federal Retirement

    Approximately 10,000 baby boomers are reaching retirement age per day, and a growing number of federal employees are preparing themselves for the next chapter of their lives. Learn how to tackle the challenges that today's workforce faces in laying the groundwork for a smooth and secure retirement.

  • Sponsored by Hewlett Packard Enterprise

    Cyber Defense 101: Arming the Next Generation of Government Employees

    Read this issue brief to learn about the sector's most potent challenges in the new cyber landscape and how government organizations are building a robust, threat-aware infrastructure

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    GBC Issue Brief: Cultivating Digital Services in the Federal Landscape

    Read this GBC issue brief to learn more about the current state of digital services in the government, and how key players are pushing enhancements towards a user-centric approach.

  • Sponsored by CDW-G

    Joint Enterprise Licensing Agreements

    Read this eBook to learn how defense agencies can achieve savings and efficiencies with an Enterprise Software Agreement.

  • Sponsored by Cloudera

    Government Forum Content Library

    Get all the essential resources needed for effective technology strategies in the federal landscape.


When you download a report, your information may be shared with the underwriters of that document.