Analysis: Pry a tax hike from the House?

Susan Walsh/AP file photo

With so many clairvoyants gaming out scenarios for avoiding the fiscal cliff, there’s one route available to Congress that has received little attention: the discharge petition.

A century-old House rule permits rank-and-file lawmakers, if they are frustrated that leaders refuse to bring a pet bill up for a floor vote, to gather signatures to pry the legislation out of committee. A majority of 218 names is required for success and it can anger the leadership, which is why the procedure is used so rarely.

There are five such petitions currently pending in the House, according to the Office of the Clerk. This July, Budget Committee ranking member Chris Van Hollen, D-Md., launched one to force the Judiciary Committee to disgorge a campaign finance disclosure bill, but it attracted only 167 signatures. And in September, Rep. Bruce Braley, D-Iowa, introduced this type of petition to force the stalled farm bill out of the Agriculture Committee, but drew only 67 names. A discharge bill from Rep. Mark Critz, D-Pa., on China’s currency policy introduced in June 2011 topped out at 179.

The most logical vehicle for a petition during the current lame-duck session is a House version of S. 3412, introduced by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., to extend the George W. Bush tax cuts for the middle and lower tax brackets but not for the wealthy. It passed the Senate, 51-48, in July and was endorsed by the White House. House Republicans, as expected, declined to take it up -- objecting on the merits, but also noting the Constitution requires revenue bills to originate in the House.

What are the odds of a House version of this legislation being the subject of a discharge position? The office of Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., declined to comment at this early stage of the in-progress budget talks. Braley’s spokesman said his boss has not considered a petition for the tax bill. But a Ways and Means minority spokesman told Government Executive that Democrats “will put pressure on Republicans at every turn to pass the Senate tax bill.”

The chances of invoking the discharge tool in this fall’s fiscal cliff drama are “slim to none as of now,” said Norm Ornstein, longtime congressional observer and resident scholar at the American Enterprise Institute, though he doesn’t rule it out.

Given that there are currently only 193 House Democrats, petitioners would need at least 25 Republicans to sign, and “there aren’t many Republicans who haven’t signed the anti-tax pledge,” Ornstein said. Many are worried about a primary challenge from their right.

Still, he ventured a scenario in which the rarely used procedure could come into play. Say, as the January deadline approaches, the Senate were to find, for example, 70 votes in favor of a bipartisan “grand bargain” deal. It could be one containing the $1.2 trillion in spending cuts and other components advocated by the bipartisan business group Fix the Debt, he said. If House Speaker John Boehner, R-Ohio, refused to bring that bill to his chamber’s floor, “there would be a major public backlash” that might make a discharge petition an option, Ornstein said.

A more skeptical take was offered by Muftiah McCartin, a special counsel at the Covington and Burling law firm and a former House parliamentarian and Rules Committee staff director. She sees a discharge petition as a “futile exercise for Democrats” because the resistance in the House comes more from the rank-and-file than from Boehner, who appears “more likely to compromise,” she said. “He doesn’t have a strong whip operation.”

Stay up-to-date with federal news alerts and analysis — Sign up for GovExec's email newsletters.
Close [ x ] More from GovExec

Thank you for subscribing to newsletters from
We think these reports might interest you:

  • Sponsored by G Suite

    Cross-Agency Teamwork, Anytime and Anywhere

    Dan McCrae, director of IT service delivery division, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA)

  • Data-Centric Security vs. Database-Level Security

    Database-level encryption had its origins in the 1990s and early 2000s in response to very basic risks which largely revolved around the theft of servers, backup tapes and other physical-layer assets. As noted in Verizon’s 2014, Data Breach Investigations Report (DBIR)1, threats today are far more advanced and dangerous.

  • Sponsored by One Identity

    One Nation Under Guard: Securing User Identities Across State and Local Government

    In 2016, the government can expect even more sophisticated threats on the horizon, making it all the more imperative that agencies enforce proper identity and access management (IAM) practices. In order to better measure the current state of IAM at the state and local level, Government Business Council (GBC) conducted an in-depth research study of state and local employees.

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    The Next Federal Evolution of Cloud

    This GBC report explains the evolution of cloud computing in federal government, and provides an outlook for the future of the cloud in government IT.

  • Sponsored by LTC Partners, administrators of the Federal Long Term Care Insurance Program

    Approaching the Brink of Federal Retirement

    Approximately 10,000 baby boomers are reaching retirement age per day, and a growing number of federal employees are preparing themselves for the next chapter of their lives. Learn how to tackle the challenges that today's workforce faces in laying the groundwork for a smooth and secure retirement.

  • Sponsored by Hewlett Packard Enterprise

    Cyber Defense 101: Arming the Next Generation of Government Employees

    Read this issue brief to learn about the sector's most potent challenges in the new cyber landscape and how government organizations are building a robust, threat-aware infrastructure

  • Sponsored by Aquilent

    GBC Issue Brief: Cultivating Digital Services in the Federal Landscape

    Read this GBC issue brief to learn more about the current state of digital services in the government, and how key players are pushing enhancements towards a user-centric approach.


When you download a report, your information may be shared with the underwriters of that document.