TOPICS

A recent monograph published by the Strategic Studies Institute at the Army War College in Carlisle, Pa., sheds new light on how children are coping with parents' multiple deployments after eight years of war in Afghanistan and Iraq.

The study, "The Effects of Multiple Deployments on Army Adolescents," reinforces much of the conventional wisdom regarding stress and deployments, but it also breaks new ground, mainly in finding no clear link between the number of deployments soldiers undertake and the level of stress their children experience.

"With almost a million children in Army families, the absence of a deployed parent will likely influence a generation of adolescents," wrote authors Leonard Wong and Stephen Gerras, both retired Army officers and now professors at the Army War College.


RELATED STORIES

Wong and Gerras examined the effects of multiple deployments through the eyes of the 2,006 soldiers they surveyed (all of whom had adolescent children and 36 percent of whom were deployed at the time), along with 718 spouses and 559 children between the ages of 11 and 17, who completed parallel versions of the study. In addition, the researchers interviewed more than 100 children at eight Army installations during the summer of 2009.

Many previous studies relied exclusively on adult perspectives -- usually from the spouse of the deployed soldier -- to assess stress levels among children, the authors noted.

Previous research showed that parents clearly associated multiple deployments with higher levels of stress among their children. Yet the Wong-Gerras study found that was not the case. Surprisingly, children aged 14 to 16 with a parent deployed reported lower stress levels than those without.

"Why would soldiers perceive a cumulative effect of deployments while adolescents report a trend of decreasing stress with each deployment?" the researchers asked. "Perhaps soldiers tend to keep a teary farewell or an emotional phone call as the salient memory of their child during a deployment. Parents may tend to forget or at least not realize that children often mature through hardships.

"Adolescents, on the other hand, may be reporting that instead of accumulating higher levels of stress with each new deployment, they have learned new coping strategies from previous experiences. In any case, the finding was unexpected, yet encouraging," Wong and Gerras wrote.

The researchers also found a surprising 56 percent of children reported they coped well or very well with a parent's deployment, while 17 percent said they coped poorly or very poorly.

"Before celebrating the unexpectedly high percentage of adolescents who claimed they handled deployments well, we must remember that the results can be extrapolated to imply that over 20,000 adolescent children in active-duty Army families alone are not coping well with deployments. ... If one out of every six Army adolescents reports doing poorly with repeated deployments, the situation can hardly be considered acceptable," Wong and Gerras wrote.

Another interesting finding of the study was a majority of children did not know how many times their parent had deployed since Sept. 11, 2001.

"While this lack of knowledge initially surprised us, upon reflection it made sense," the report noted. "A 13-year-old girl, for example, may be unable to recount her experience with deployments from the time she was a 5-year-old. Nor is it unreasonable for a 12-year-old boy enduring his third deployment to be unsure whether his deployed father is currently in Iraq or Afghanistan."

The authors found that high participation levels in activities -- especially sports, a strong family and an adolescent's belief that the country supports the war in which his parent is fighting were important factors in lower stress levels. The strongest predictor of ability to cope, they noted, was the child's perception that his parent was making a difference.

"Multiple deployments have become a way of life for our soldiers," wrote Gen. Charles Campbell, the top officer at Army Forces Command, in a foreword to the study. "This study goes beyond merely explaining the impact eight years of war is having on the children of our soldiers; rather, it explores specific factors that increase or alleviate stress on Army adolescents."

As such, the study and should influence policymakers, military leaders and parents "in this era of persistent conflict," Campbell wrote.

COMMENTS

  • I have to see the complete study to understand this. My husband is in the Army National Guard, and I am in the Air National Guard. He has a 15 y/o daughter from a previous relationship and we have a three y/o daughter, and a 5 m/o son. This is his second deployment to Iraq. Maybe our family is part of the small percentage but the kids (besides the baby) are not handling it well. The teenager has more of a social life, but it still affects her. The three y/o is the worst. The other night she had a 10-12 hour temper tantrum. Even when she was sleeping she was still crying for her daddy in her sleep. Don't even get me started on double deployments. Luckily I only have to worry about it during Hurricane season. So far I view this story as bogus.
  • As a Reservist - when they deploy they are away from the family for approximately 15 months - they way they are deploying currently is home a couple weeks gone a couple of weeks to train. If that is not difficult on families I dont know what is. Yes the communication is much easier but that can be difficult also when your talking with the family and they hear the explosions behind you. They get your gut reactions vs a tempered written letter. I watched my son go from a bean pole kid of 5 to a chubby kid of 10 from 9-11 thru 2006 when my last deployment ended. While I am still in (soon to retire) its bunk to think that kids are handling it well. It is extremely hard on kids with no support system - away from a military base. Teachers who hate the military (or the war), kids asking all the time so your dad died yet killed anyone yet etc. And where I am the Air Guard gets all the attention but yet they only deploy for about 3 months at a time while the Army is gone at least 15 months at a time. Quite often longer than the Active Duty units.
  • This study is one big bag full of horse dung and alot of wishful thinking on the authors part. Or mabey it was written to the whims of upper level management, so all these deployments don't look bad to the average US citizen. Well the administration doesn't have to worry. The reason being, unless your one of those poor people on repeat deployments no one cares. The average person making these pumps is always thinking, How many times can I be lucky enough to come back in one piece. And to think this thought isn't going through the minds of the whole family, then there's something wrong with your mind. I lived it for twenty years, I saw my kids faces when I came home from mulitiple pumps and believe me I saw the stress. I saw it in copies of report cards that were sent, I saw it in pics I recieved. I knew when things were right and wrong just by looking at their pictures. So don't tell me some study says the children of people pulling multiple deployments into combat zones have low stress, becuase it's just not true.