GovernmentExecutive.com

Return to Article: Justice official defends PATRIOT Act

• 6644
  

  Despite the many conspiracy theories that exist today, the truth is that there is no way for the government to find out what you checked out of the library, other than by going to the library itself. There are too many public and private libraries in this country, each with their own systems of records, for the government to do this. Regarding credit cards, the FBI or any other law enforcement agency must rely on the companies themselves, who respond to subpoenas or other legal orders, and provide the requested information (no, "Big Brother" does not have a supercomputer with all your info. on it). As far as the rights of New Yorkers to protest, I worked at the RNC, and thousands of people, including many from outside New York, did protest, peacefully, without interference from the police. Those who were arrested were definitely in the minority, and for the most part, were arrested for breaking the law. Sorry to burst your bubble, but after 24 years in federal law enforcement, I can proudly say that I have never violated anyone's rights, nor has anyone else I have worked with. There are bad apples in every barrel, but they are in the minority, and are prosecuted for their wrongdoing. If you can give specifics regarding what you allege, then do so. Otherwise, stop spreading rumors and innuendo!

  GovExec.com reader Posted October 13, 2004 10:27 AM
• 6611
  

  Please- what do you mean go through records.

  The FBI can currently track any American when they use their credit cards. All you folks have to do is receive a message anytime someone takes out a book on your watch list. Can you imagine what Mr. Hoover would have done with such technology and to anybody who borrowed such authors as Marx and Engels.

  Mr. Special Agent- I hate to burst your bubble but when you trash the Constitution to win a war against an enemy who wants to trash the Constitution you've just let them win. I appreciate being called Paranoid- I wish to God some of my relatives were more paranoid in the 1930s.

  And I think people like you are doing a pretty job of putting us back into the Dark Ages of 1004 AD without the help of these terrorists. Tell me, how do you win this war without making America into a Police State?

  To quote our esteemed Special Agent:

  "The reality is that those of us in law enforcement are too busy going after real bad guys to randomly violate your rights."

  This is good news- so the violation of the civil rights, e.g. the rights of New Yorkers to protest the Republican Convention, wasn't a random violation. Good to know there is a plan to violate these Civil rights. I think even our friends in law enforcement should take pause because all you folks are in same boat as the rest of America.

  GovExec.com reader Posted October 12, 2004 8:27 AM
• 6510
  

  Please stop whining about the Patriot Act! Nobody in their right mind is going to go through the public library records of almost 300 million Americans. Who has the time, and who cares?! However, this can be a useful tool to help investigate the relative handful of terrorists hiding among us. The last time I read the Constitution, I didn't see where it granted any specific rights for terrorists to use the resources of our own public libraries against us! The reality is that those of us in law enforcement are too busy going after real bad guys to randomly violate your rights, so stop being so paranoid, and grow up! Remember that we are at war with enemies who, if they win, would be the first to trash the Constitution and bring the world back a thousand years! A little perspective, please!!!

  GovExec.com reader Posted October 5, 2004 11:52 AM
• 6481
  

  Judiciary Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, defended the act, saying that law enforcement officials have been allowed to inspect library records for years and that "there is no constitutional issue about not immediately notifying people about warrants."

  Way to go Orrin! Then obviously there is no need for the act! Let it expire! The act is as anti-american as is the invasion of IRAQ!

  tax payer Posted October 4, 2004 10:46 AM
• 6422
  

  Sometimes I think the Justice Department should change its name to the US Political Department because these so-called Lawyers don't have a clue about our constitutional civil rights.

  Another great quote from this administration:

  "Comey said law enforcement agents need to search records of libraries because terrorists have in the past planned attacks using public library computers for e-mail. He added, "We don't want libraries to be a sanctuary in this country, if you think about it."

  So let's see- to stop a potential terrorist from possibly using a public library computer to plan an attack the government needs the power to search what I have been reading over my lifetime or to go to a bookstore and search what books I've purchased.

  Our liberty is really, really fragile. I took an oath to uphold the Constitution of the United States of America-- WE THE PEOPLE... PROMOTE THE BLESSINGS OF LIBERTY.. etc. etc. etc.

  Not you the government, we the people.

  It is so very sad that on and on we read that security is preempting our civil liberties and not a peep from the American people. So many have died so that we can have the blessing of liberty and now so many wish to just hand it over to people like Deputy Attorney General Comey who appears to have forgotten the oath he took to uphold the Constitution of the United States-- which includes a little thing called a Bill of Rights.

  GovExec.com reader Posted September 29, 2004 3:20 PM