Whose Intelligence is Better?

By Charles S. Clark

September 17, 2012

The Sunday talk shows’ dissections of who’s to blame for the attacks on U.S. outposts in Arab nations included an eye-opening statement from Liz Cheney, former principal deputy assistant secretary of State for near eastern affairs. In a blast at the Obama administration on ABC’s “This Week,” the daughter of former Vice President Dick Cheney went after the effectiveness of the overall U.S. intelligence effort going back a decade.

“The key on the intelligence here, it wasn't just India that we missed. It was also, frankly, Syria, the nuclear power plant that was being built in the Syrian desert, which was in 2007 that the Israelis came to us and said, "Here, we have it." On Iraq, the Israelis had better intelligence than we did about the development of that nuclear program. …I think that our own intelligence has not been very effective at identifying and predicting where other nations stand in this.”

Asked by Government Executive to respond, Paul R. Pillar, who retired after 28 years with CIA who worked on the Iraq intelligence estimates, said, ”What Israeli intelligence? Did Israeli intelligence say Saddam did not have an active nuclear weapons program in 2002-2003? That's a new one on me.” He added that “the nature and extent of India's program was not 'missed’ at all.”


By Charles S. Clark

September 17, 2012

http://www.govexec.com/federal-news/fedblog/2012/09/whose-intelligence-better/58151/