TOPICS

Presumptive Republican nominee John McCain on Monday repeated his pledge to provide veterans with the option of seeking medical care outside the Veterans Affairs health system if they do not have convenient access to a VA facility.

In a speech before the National Convention of Veterans of Foreign Wars in Orlando, Fla., the Arizona senator said a veterans' care access card is necessary for low-income vets and those with injuries or illnesses incurred during military service.

"This card will provide those without timely access to VA facilities the option of using high-quality health care providers near their homes," McCain said. "For many veterans, the closest VA facility isn't close enough."


RELATED STORIES

He said while many of veterans' local health care providers are familiar already with their patients' needs, the absence of an information-sharing system among the federal government, civilian hospitals and doctors, is an obstacle.

McCain responded to the proposal's critics by insisting that the card is not intended to replace VA or privatize veterans' health care. VA should be there always to provide care for veterans, including specialized care in areas like spinal injuries, prosthetics and blindness, where VA "sets the standard," he said.

"My reforms would not force anyone to go to a non-VA facility," McCain said. "They will not signal privatization of the VA, and they will not replace any scheduled expansion of the VA network -- including those facilities designed to serve veterans living in rural and remote areas."

The Veterans of Foreign Wars does not support the access card. Dennis Cullinan, VFW's national legislative director, said the card would take funding and patients away from VA, "undermining the entire system over time."

Cullinan said the agency already has the ability to provide contract care in areas where a VA facility is not available or does not have the capability to address a certain medical need. But if one group of veterans were given a card to go outside the VA system, he said, others likely would demand the same option.

Rep. Bob Filner, D-Calif., and chairman of the House Committee on Veterans Affairs, said it is unclear in McCain's speech who exactly would receive the access cards and that giving the cards to everyone is "absolutely privatization."

"If you determine on a case-by-case basis or based on geographical area that there is a need to do this for better access, that's one thing; giving it to everyone is another thing," Filner said. "That's the end of the VA."

He also noted that McCain has not detailed any cost control measures that would be attached to the access card.

McCain said an access card would help the agency bridge the existing gap in care for women. As the number of women in uniform has grown dramatically, VA has lagged behind in the services it provides, he said.

"Here the veterans care access card will prove especially valuable, affording women medical options while the VA improves capacity and expands services," McCain said.

McCain said he would build on existing legislation to improve screening and treatment for post-traumatic stress disorder and traumatic brain injury. He also stressed the importance of finding the right leader for the department.

"My VA secretary must be a forceful advocate for veterans and forthright adviser to me, so we can make the right choices about budgeting, health care and other veterans' benefit issues," McCain said. "He or she will also need to be a high-energy leader, too, because we'll have a lot of work to do in improving service to veterans."

COMMENTS

  • Veteran care is an issue, and anyone who has been to a VA facility knows this. One troublesome factor I noticed about the VA is most of the employees are not veterans and the VA employees actually hold vets in comtempt, like we are bottom feeders. So yea, most veterans will want to jump the VA ship if there is an access card option. Mailing via fedex a card back and forth when one of the parties is very ill is not an answer. There will still be a VA as the VA is two parts one part medical and one part benefits that include life insurance, education benefits, etc. Start VA reform by hiring Vets for jobs at the VA.
  • Of course McCain is for our Vets. Let's see who should I vote for this Nov., an old war hero, or an anti american racist. Hmmm hard choice.
  • If a medical card "IS" pushed through by the special interest groups supporting John McCain by the private hospital H.M.Os,this will be a disaster and will end up hurting all veterans.If implemented , which i doubt, the card should be kept at the VA instead of given out to the Veterans like candy.When the VA gives it out it should be a temporary card with a 24 hour expiration.That way the temptation for fraud at the private hospitals which we know will happen,can be controlled.If the Veteran lives a long way from the VA the VA can mail the Veteran the card by certified mail so the Veteran can go to the nearest hospital that takes VA patients.The card should be tightly controlled and only given out in special circumstances,it should also be signed for and returned to VA by return mail once used, at VA expense.The John McCain proposal will open up the system to massive fraud as in medicare.Instead of a card Washington needs to hire more qualified doctors and pay them more so as to give them a incentive to stay with the VA. The VA cannot keep good doctors because they are overworked and underpaid.When i go to the EL Paso Texas VA, the doctors are running around like crazy just trying to keep up and the nurse shortage at EL Paso VA does not help either.